A powerful new documentary is shining a spotlight on conditions within Alabama’s prison system, raising significant questions about civil rights, constitutional protections, and legal accountability in the state’s correctional facilities.
The Documentary’s Revelations
“The Alabama Solution,” directed by Andrew Jarecki and Charlotte Kaufman, premiered at the Sundance Film Festival on January 21, 2025. The film documents conditions inside Alabama state prisons through footage captured covertly by incarcerated people using contraband cellphones.
The documentary, filmed over six years, reveals disturbing scenes: blood-streaked floors, rat-infested cells, flooded hallways, and incidents of officer violence against inmates. These conditions persist despite a December 2020 U.S. Justice Department report that deemed the situation in Alabama prisons “unconstitutional.”
According to information presented in the film, Alabama’s prisons currently operate at 200% capacity with only one-third of the required staff. The documentary also states that Alabama’s correctional facilities have the highest rates of murder, drug addiction, and death among state prison systems nationwide.
Steven Davis Case: A Family’s Legal Battle
Among the most compelling narratives in the film is the story of Sandy Ray, mother of Steven Davis, who was killed by officers at William E. Donaldson Correctional Facility in October 2019.
The documentary follows Ray’s three-year quest for information and justice. According to the Alabama Department of Corrections (ADOC), Davis threatened officers with a knife, necessitating physical force. However, witnesses interviewed in the film claimed Davis only had a plastic knife, which he discarded when ordered to lie on the ground.
After an extended investigation, the state declined to press criminal charges against the officers involved. In 2022, Ray settled a civil lawsuit for $250,000, with the state never admitting wrongdoing. The officer primarily implicated in Davis’s death, according to the documentary, has since received two promotions.
The film notes that Alabama has spent $51 million defending officers from misconduct lawsuits over the past five years, with the state covering legal expenses for all officers named in such cases.
Federal Intervention and State Response
In December 2020, the U.S. Justice Department sued Alabama over prison conditions after its investigation found “systematic” violence and abuse. Governor Kay Ivey responded by characterizing the situation as “an Alabama solution to an Alabama problem.”
The state’s approach has primarily focused on facility expansion rather than operational reform. In 2021, Alabama diverted $400 million in federal COVID-19 relief funds and $100 million from the state’s education budget toward the construction of three new prisons.
Meanwhile, according to statistics presented in the film, parole approval rates have decreased by 72% in recent years, contributing to ongoing overcrowding.
Civil Rights Litigation in Alabama Prisons
The documentary highlights ongoing class-action litigation against the Alabama Department of Corrections, led by incarcerated activist Robert Earl “Kinetik Justice” Council. This lawsuit, along with the Justice Department’s case, remains in active litigation as of March 2025.
These legal challenges raise critical questions about constitutional rights that persist even after incarceration:
- Eighth Amendment Protections: The prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment includes the right to safe conditions, adequate medical care, and protection from violence.
- Fourteenth Amendment Due Process: Incarcerated individuals retain due process rights regarding disciplinary actions, classification decisions, and other administrative proceedings.
- First Amendment Rights: While limited, people in prison maintain certain free speech and religious expression rights that cannot be arbitrarily denied.
- Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Compliance: Prisons must provide reasonable accommodations for incarcerated people with disabilities.
Understanding these constitutional protections is essential for incarcerated individuals and their families seeking to address rights violations through Alabama’s legal system.
Legal Remedies for Constitutional Violations
For individuals who have experienced rights violations within Alabama’s prison system, several legal remedies exist:
- Civil Rights Lawsuits: Under Section 1983 of the Civil Rights Act, individuals can sue state officials who violate their constitutional rights. These cases can seek both monetary damages and injunctive relief to stop ongoing violations.
- Class Action Litigation: When violations affect many incarcerated people similarly, class actions can address systemic problems more effectively than individual lawsuits.
- Administrative Remedies: The Prison Litigation Reform Act requires exhausting internal grievance procedures before filing federal lawsuits, making documentation of complaints essential.
- Wrongful Death Claims: Families of those who die due to prison conditions or staff misconduct can pursue wrongful death actions, though Alabama’s statute provides only for punitive damages rather than compensatory damages.
- Federal Intervention: The Department of Justice can investigate and litigate against state prison systems that demonstrate patterns of constitutional violations.
Success in these cases often depends on thorough documentation, credible witness testimony, and expert analysis—all challenges given the restricted access to information within prison environments.
The Future of Prison Reform in Alabama
The documentary concludes with footage of a statewide prisoner strike organized in October 2022 demanding improved conditions. Despite gaining national media attention, Governor Ivey deemed the strikers’ demands “unreasonable,” according to the film.
Legal experts suggest that significant reform in Alabama will likely require continued pressure through both litigation and public awareness. Historically, Alabama has often implemented civil rights reforms only after federal intervention, a pattern the documentary traces from the Civil War through the Civil Rights Movement to the present day.
A class-action lawsuit against the ADOC continues to move through federal court, potentially creating precedents that could affect not only Alabama’s prisons but correctional systems nationwide.
How Baxley Maniscalco Can Help
At Baxley Maniscalco, we understand the complex intersection of civil rights law and personal injury claims in Alabama.
For families who have lost loved ones due to misconduct or negligence within state institutions, or individuals who have experienced constitutional rights violations, our experienced attorneys can:
- Evaluate potential claims under federal civil rights statutes and state law.
- Navigate the complex administrative requirements for bringing claims against government entities.
- Assemble the documentation and expert testimony needed to demonstrate violations.
- Represent families in wrongful death litigation involving state agencies.
- Ensure compliance with notice requirements and filing deadlines specific to government claims.
The legal landscape surrounding institutional civil rights violations is complex, but accountability is possible through careful legal strategy and determined advocacy.
Free consultation
Search our site
Browse our blog
