Effects of Pre-Existing Conditions on Personal Injury Claims in Alabama

---

Pre-existing conditions are health issues or injuries that an individual had before being involved in an accident. 

These can include:

• Chronic illnesses (e.g., diabetes, arthritis);
• Previous injuries (e.g., back problems, knee injuries);
• Degenerative conditions (e.g., osteoporosis);
• Mental health disorders; and
• Congenital conditions.

Understanding what qualifies as a pre-existing condition is crucial when pursuing a personal injury claim in Alabama.

The Eggshell Plaintiff Rule in Alabama

Alabama, like many states, follows the “eggshell plaintiff” rule (sometimes referred to as the eggshell skull rule). This legal doctrine states that a defendant takes the plaintiff as they find them, regardless of any pre-existing conditions or vulnerabilities. 

Key points include:

• Defendants are responsible for all injuries caused, even if they’re more severe due to pre-existing conditions;
• The rule protects plaintiffs with pre-existing conditions from being unfairly disadvantaged in personal injury claims; and
• It doesn’t allow plaintiffs to claim compensation for conditions unrelated to the accident.

Understanding this rule is essential for both plaintiffs and defendants in Alabama personal injury cases.

How Pre-Existing Conditions Affect Personal Injury Claims

Pre-existing conditions can impact personal injury claims in several ways:

• Complicating causation: It may be challenging to determine which symptoms are from the accident and which are from pre-existing conditions.

• Affecting compensation: Pre-existing conditions might increase the amount of compensation if the accident exacerbated them.

• Influencing settlement negotiations: Insurance companies may use pre-existing conditions to argue for lower settlements.

• Impacting medical treatment: The presence of pre-existing conditions might necessitate different or more extensive medical care.

• Extending recovery time: Pre-existing conditions could prolong the recovery period, affecting lost wages and other damages.

Understanding these effects is crucial for building a strong personal injury case in Alabama.

Challenges in Proving Aggravation of Pre-Existing Conditions

Demonstrating that an accident worsened a pre-existing condition can be challenging. Common hurdles include:

• Lack of clear medical evidence distinguishing new from old injuries;
• Insurance company tactics to minimize the accident’s impact;
• Difficulty in quantifying the extent of aggravation; and
• Proving that the accident, not natural progression, caused the worsening.

Overcoming these challenges often requires expert medical testimony and thorough documentation.

Importance of Medical Documentation

Proper medical documentation is crucial in personal injury cases involving pre-existing conditions. 

Key aspects include:

• Comprehensive medical history: Providing a clear picture of your health before the accident;

• Immediate post-accident care: Documenting all treatments and diagnoses following the incident;

• Ongoing medical assessments: Regular check-ups to track changes in your condition; and

• Expert medical opinions: Statements from specialists about the accident’s impact on pre-existing conditions.

Maintaining detailed records can significantly strengthen your case in Alabama courts.

Strategies for Handling Pre-Existing Conditions in Your Claim

To effectively manage pre-existing conditions in your personal injury claim:

• Be honest about your medical history;
• Seek immediate medical attention after an accident;
• Follow all prescribed treatments and attend all appointments;
• Keep detailed records of symptoms and how they differ from pre-accident conditions;
• Consider consulting with medical experts who can clearly explain the accident’s impact; and
• Work with an experienced personal injury attorney familiar with Alabama law.

These strategies can help you build a stronger case and improve your chances of fair compensation.

Alabama Laws Relevant to Pre-Existing Conditions and Personal Injury

Several Alabama laws and legal principles are particularly relevant to personal injury cases involving pre-existing conditions:

• Contributory negligence: Alabama is one of the few states that follow this rule, which can bar recovery if the plaintiff is found even slightly at fault.

• Statute of limitations: In Alabama, personal injury claims must typically be filed within two years of the accident.

• Collateral source rule: This rule can affect how compensation from other sources (like health insurance) is considered in your claim.

Understanding these laws is crucial for navigating your personal injury claim effectively.

Common Misconceptions About Pre-Existing Conditions

Several myths surround pre-existing conditions in personal injury claims.

Myth #1: You can’t claim compensation if you have a pre-existing condition.

Reality: The eggshell plaintiff rule protects your right to compensation for aggravated conditions.

Myth #2: Insurance companies will automatically deny claims involving pre-existing conditions.

Reality: While they may complicate claims, pre-existing conditions don’t automatically disqualify you from compensation.

Myth #3: You must disclose all medical history, even if unrelated to your claim.

Reality: While honesty is crucial, you’re generally only required to disclose relevant medical information.

Myth #4: Pre-existing conditions always reduce the value of your claim.

Reality: In some cases, pre-existing conditions can actually increase compensation if the accident significantly worsens them.

Understanding these realities can help you approach your claim with confidence and realistic expectations.

Frequently Asked Questions

To help you better understand how pre-existing conditions affect personal injury claims in Alabama, we’ve compiled answers to some of the most common questions we receive:

Can I Still File a Personal Injury Claim If I Have a Pre-Existing Condition?

Yes, you can still file a claim. The key is demonstrating how the accident worsened your condition or caused new injuries.

How Do I Prove That My Pre-Existing Condition Was Aggravated by the Accident?

Medical documentation, expert testimony, and before-and-after comparisons of your condition are crucial for proving aggravation.

Will My Pre-Existing Condition Affect the Amount of Compensation I Can Receive?

It may affect compensation, but not always negatively. If the accident significantly worsened your condition, you might be entitled to more compensation.

Should I Disclose My Pre-Existing Conditions to My Attorney?

Yes, always be honest with your attorney. They need this information to build the strongest possible case for you.

How Long Do I Have to File a Personal Injury Claim in Alabama?

In Alabama, the statute of limitations for most personal injury claims is two years from the date of the accident.

Can the Insurance Company Access My Entire Medical History?

They may request relevant medical records, but you have rights regarding privacy and the scope of disclosure.

What If My Pre-Existing Condition Was Asymptomatic Before the Accident?

If an asymptomatic condition becomes symptomatic after an accident, you may still have a valid claim for the new or aggravated symptoms.

Next Steps in Your Personal Injury Claim

Don’t let pre-existing conditions complicate your path to justice. 

At Baxley Maniscalco, our experienced attorneys understand the intricacies of personal injury claims involving pre-existing conditions in Alabama. 

We’re here to help you navigate this complex process and fight for the compensation you deserve. 
Contact us today for a free consultation and take the first step towards protecting your rights and securing fair compensation.