The tranquil waters of Lewis Smith Lake turned tragic on an April day in 2025, when a high-speed boat collision during a professional bass fishing tournament claimed three lives and left two others seriously injured.
Now, months after the devastating crash, a Georgia man faces serious criminal charges that highlight the critical importance of boating safety and operator responsibility on Alabama’s waterways.
The Indictment: Criminal Charges Filed
On October 3, 2025, a Cullman County grand jury indicted Flint Andrew Davis, 22, of Leesburg, Georgia, on multiple felony and misdemeanor charges related to the fatal boat crash. The charges paint a picture of alleged negligence that resulted in catastrophic consequences.
The grand jury handed down the following charges:
- Three counts of reckless manslaughter (felonies).
- Two counts of first-degree assault (felonies).
- Reckless operation of a vessel (misdemeanor).
- Failing to follow boating rules (misdemeanor).
- Boating without a boater safety certification (misdemeanor).
These charges represent the culmination of months of investigation by Alabama Marine Patrol and reflect the severity of the incident that shocked both the fishing community and local residents who regularly enjoy Lewis Smith Lake’s recreational opportunities.
The Fatal Collision: What Happened on Lewis Smith Lake
The crash occurred during the second day of the Tackle Warehouse Invitational, a bass fishing tournament organized by Major League Fishing.
According to investigators, Davis was participating in the tournament when his boat, traveling at 67 mph, struck another vessel on the lake, approximately 70 miles north of Birmingham.
Video evidence captured the horrifying moment when Davis’ boat collided with the other craft, launching into the air upon impact. The victims were not tournament participants but were enjoying a company-sponsored fishing trip when tragedy struck.
The collision resulted in:
- Joey M. Broom, 58, of Snead, Alabama, suffered fatal injuries in the impact.
- John K. Clark, 44, of Cullman, Alabama, was thrown overboard and drowned.
- Jeffrey C. Little, 62, of Brandon, Mississippi, was ejected from the boat and drowned.
- Two additional men sustained serious injuries requiring medical attention.
The loss of three lives in a single boating incident represents one of the most serious marine accidents on Alabama waterways in recent years, prompting renewed calls for enhanced boating safety regulations.
Investigation Findings: Beyond Speed
While Davis’ boat was traveling at 67 mph at the time of impact, Alabama Marine Patrol Chief Matt Brooks stated at an October 4, 2025 news conference that speed was not the primary factor in the crash.
Instead, investigators determined the collision resulted from “operator inattention, distraction, not paying attention, failing to keep a proper lookout.”
Key findings from the investigation revealed:
- Davis “clearly did not see” the other boat before impact.
- The operator lacked required boating licenses in both Georgia and Alabama.
- No evidence of alcohol or drug impairment was found.
- The crash was attributed to failure to maintain proper vigilance while operating the vessel.
These findings underscore the critical importance of maintaining constant awareness while operating watercraft, particularly at high speeds during competitive events where focus on fishing activities can potentially divide an operator’s attention.
Legal Implications and Defense Response
Currently free on bail following his arrest, Davis faces serious legal consequences if convicted on all charges.
The combination of felony manslaughter and assault charges could result in significant prison time and substantial fines under Alabama law.
Understanding how personal injury settlements work is crucial for those affected by such tragedies.
Attorney Tommy Spina, representing Davis, issued a statement expressing his client’s “deepest remorse and contrition” to the families of the deceased and injured.
Spina confirmed that Davis was neither under the influence of substances nor otherwise distracted, stating, “He simply did not see the other boat until the moment of impact.”
The defense attorney indicated that “many possible explanations” exist for the collision but emphasized these matters would be addressed in court rather than through media statements.
This approach suggests the defense may challenge aspects of the prosecution’s case regarding the specific cause of Davis’ alleged inattention.
Civil Litigation and Regulatory Reform
Beyond the criminal proceedings, multiple wrongful death lawsuits have been filed seeking civil damages from the incident. These civil cases will proceed independently of the criminal prosecution and could result in substantial financial judgments for the victims’ families.
The tragedy has also sparked legislative discussions about fishing tournament regulations in Alabama. Cullman County District Attorney Champ Crocker noted that grand jurors recommended:
- Mandatory proof of boating licenses for all fishing tournament participants.
- Enhanced safety promotion requirements for tournament organizers.
- Stricter oversight of competitive fishing events on public waterways.
These recommendations reflect growing concerns about the balance between competitive fishing activities and public safety on Alabama’s lakes and waterways.
The Broader Impact on Alabama’s Boating Community
This case serves as a sobering reminder of the responsibilities that come with operating watercraft in Alabama.
The state’s numerous lakes and waterways attract thousands of recreational boaters and fishing enthusiasts annually, making proper safety protocols and operator awareness essential for preventing future tragedies.
The incident highlights several critical safety considerations:
- The importance of maintaining proper boating licenses and certifications.
- The need for constant vigilance regardless of speed or activity.
- The potential consequences of momentary inattention on the water.
- The responsibility of tournament organizers to ensure participant compliance with safety regulations.
As this case proceeds through the criminal justice system, it will likely influence future boating safety initiatives and potentially lead to stricter regulations for competitive fishing events throughout Alabama.
Let Justice Roll
Boating accidents can result in devastating consequences, including criminal charges, civil liability, and life-altering injuries or fatalities.
Whether you’re facing criminal charges related to a boating incident or seeking compensation for injuries sustained in a marine accident, understanding your legal rights and options is crucial.
Our experienced personal injury attorneys here at Baxley Maniscalco understand the complexities of maritime law and Alabama’s specific boating regulations.
We can help navigate the legal challenges that arise from boating accidents, whether you’re dealing with criminal charges, civil lawsuits, or insurance claims. If you or a loved one has been affected by a boating accident in Alabama, don’t face these challenges alone.
Contact Baxley Maniscalco today at (256) 770-7232 to schedule a consultation and learn how we can protect your rights and pursue the justice you deserve.
Can't find what you're looking for? Search our site below.
Read More
